Beautiful Fragile Things
I woke up early this morning to plunder and remember. Here in Seattle, the local glass artists at Art by Fire have been busy. Together they’ve been blowing glass balls to mark the second anniversary of the 9-11 attacks. Last night, after dark when the park was closed, they tucked nine hundred and eleven of them into the sea grass and between the breakwater boulders of Golden Gardens at Shilshole Bay. In the morning residents were invited to comb the beach for these colorful surprises. I was at the park by dawn’s early light. The park, popular in the summer but typically abandoned at 6:30am on a Saturday, was crawling with people, empty handed and disappointed. One mother I passed was trying to explain to her sleepy child that people had “cheated” by coming before daylight. I kid you not, the child replied, “Look at the big ocean mommy!”
I felt chagrined that I had come so eagerly out of bed to find a bauble. I knew that I would not have come if it were to hang ribbons on a tree or to run a race to raise money for some sort of rebuilding effort. But because there was something beautiful involved, and it was free, I was there. I knew that I would not have gone to purchase such a memorial, at sixty dollars or a hundred, in one of the many glass stores in the area. I wanted to be a part of an artistic Easter egg hunt, and I felt small about it.
I live as far away from the sad events of 9-11 as anyone in our country can. The only thing that ties me to it is a deep love for the city, a lifelong yearning to live a year in New York, and the fact that when you come to the base of the hill I live on, the eye is cut with a silver thread of towers which lines my sky. Still, despite this tenuous tie, beyond the fact that I wanted to hold something pretty and fragile, I think there is something in me that wants to hold on to 9-11, something terrible and hard. It is like a scar somewhere deep in the fascia. You can’t really feel it unless you press, dig around a bit with the pads of your fingers. But then you find it, a long hard line that rolls a bit when you push on it, there on the soft underside of your forearm. I’m not sure what that is, but I’m sure I don’t want to forget about it, to let it become an un-noticed part of my physical landscape.
I decided to stay at the beach this morning and I perched myself on an outcropping rock a few feet below the edge of the walking path. I wished that I could tell myself, “What are all these people doing here disturbing the sanctity of my every-Saturday-morning holy spot? Oh? There are artworks floating on the surface. I had no idea!” But I could not convince myself of this meritous tale. So I did my best to hide from the throngs, to feel the wind which was coming strongly from the southwest, and to appreciate this urban delight which April misses so much. It took me a long time to tune out the conversations above me, and the last desperate searchers peaking under each outcropping below me.
What has 9-11 really taught us? How has it changed us? Angry men crumbled our symbol of commerce. Has it made commercialism less of a deity? A desperate team destroyed life on the altar of military might. Did it cause us to remember the wise teachings of Buddha: “All men love life. All men fear death. Remember that you are like unto them and do not kill or cause bloodshed.”? The Twin Towers, the Pentagon – symbols of wealth and power. Did we redouble our efforts to distribute some of the wealth and power to those in need? Did we remember Dafur? Did we treat the orphaned fall out of AIDS? Did we recruit youngest and impoverished men and women to training schools, to college grants? Did we seek peace?
If the goal of those terrorist was, in part, to punish us for our greed, for our hoarding of resource and might, then it is true, they did not win. But if their goal was to take a nation with ideals of freedom, and wrap it in fear, well, then three years of ‘code orange’ and random acts of aggression would certainly indicate a victory.
When those artists dreamed of floating fragile beautiful things in the edge of the sea, perhaps deep called to deep. Maybe, below the scar, it reminded me that somewhere in an even deeper place there was something in me that wanted to resist the victory of fear. Maybe the fire blowers touched that. Maybe they caught that up in some collective consciousness and melted it into symbol. Perhaps they were calling to all of us to be victorious in more ways than one. To give away things that would otherwise bring us wealth. To harness the power we have access to – fire and breath – and offer it as a gift, unexpected and unbidden. And perhaps my muse caught on to the brilliance of their muse and wanted to be there. Maybe that is what drew me out of bed on a stormy weekend morning. I’d like to think so. I’d like to hope.


beautiful wonderings on this memorial day rachelle. i too would have joined you for a tangible memorial of that day. all i have are my memories, and compared to so many they seem insignificant. having something to hold on to would have made me feel more a part of things.
i was hoping that by the end of your story you would tell me that there, under a rock one peeked out at you, safe and hidden until your eyes found it waiting. this day is for all of us somehow. others more than me, but mine none the less.
i hope to honor it by living in a different way than i did 3 years ago, wanting and striving for things to be different, better somehow. i will use this day forever in my life as a touchstone. a benchmark to see how i was forever changed.
Does the actions on 9/11 three years ago account for those causing the suffering in the Sudan that have the same mindset as those terrorists.
Certanly the Sudan is not a center of wealth and power that the U.S. is.
Is the U.S. the source of the problem for militant followers of Islam, or is it something else?
I love what you said about collective consciousness being melted into symbol. Many people have said that one positive thing to come out of 911 is regaining our national symbols - that they have become meaningful to us again.
I wish that somehow the symbols of the church would regain their meaning for us. I think we have lost much of that, and we are weaker because of it.
We Canadians watch what America does with some smugness (alas), but increasing anxiety. 9/11 continues to impact us as well, effecting a much less dramatic but no less real polarization of our society. We cannot escape whatever happens south of us: even the results of your November election will impact us in ways we can’t imagine.
Your sensitive, thoughtful comments are cheering at least to me, Rachelle. They indicate what i already felt, that many Americans are not blinded by the crush of patriotic sentiment, not fueled by greed and paranoia , but are trying to make some sense of 9/11 and its fallout in ways that take into account the entire planet, not just the 50 States.